2005:
Thrive Or Jive?
Every
year around this time, some know-it-all pundit writes a slogging,
pointless treatise that predicts the big trends that will drive the
music industry in the coming year. Such articles are seldom correct,
although they often share a tinge of insight about the general
course that the ever-changing industry might take.
There are two
exceptions: Either the writer in question makes such broad and
obvious predictions that the piece amounts to a litany of bland
blather. Or the writer posits such vagaries that the forecasts take
on a Nostradamus-like quality, cleverly crafted as to always be
retroactively correct.
To be sure,
specifically predicting what will happen in the next year in the
music world is practically fruitless. But alas, we can try to put
forth a few ideas about the direction things might take—and, of
course, what this means for artists, labels and the many other camps
that make a living in this often low-margin and thankless—but oh
so irresistible and fun—music business.
Certainly the
Internet is by far the biggest, baddest, most incredibly influential
monster to utterly turn a multi-billion dollar industry upside down
since… well, since never, really. Anyone who wants to put up a Web
site and sell music globally can do so. Anyone can share music with
anyone else anywhere. Copying music is quick, easy and free.
That’s the
Internet, and while it’s been around now for a while, the massive
adoption of broadband services over the last couple of years has
turned it into a medium on steroids. And there are now thousands of
personal trainers out there ready to pump you up, whether you’re
an artist, an indie label, a club owner… whatever. It’s a new
world. And the old powers are searching desperately for a way to
survive without the gatekeeper—and spending millions in the
process.
These factors are
making the Web a vital tool for independent artists in 2005 and
beyond. "I have been selling music on the Internet for the past
four years and have watched my own sales, and audience, grow
using only the Internet around the world," says indie recording
artist Stacye Branche. "With little to
no money, an indie artist is able to reach a worldwide
audience." Of course, the Internet can’t negate the daily
struggle that all Indie artists must endure, but
"the advantages such as being able to be
yourself, creating the kind of music that you really want
to create, and not having someone else make all the
money while dictating your future, so outweigh any of the
disadvantages," she says.
Indeed, Branche and
countless other artists can now do it themselves without the label
backing once considered crucial. While labels still can be vital in
helping with marketing, promotion and distribution, the Internet has
helped many artists see a future without a label (or perhaps one
forged by their own hand, with their own label).
In addition, more
independent artists are looking at their music as a promotional
vehicle, often either giving it away online or understanding that
peer-to-peer services make it almost impossible to stop people from
taking it. How can indie artists adjust in 2005 as broadband
networks increase the downloading phenomenon?
"Artists will no
longer prosper by selling their recorded music," predicts Jerry
Goolsby, distinguished chair of Music Industry Studies at Loyola
University in New Orleans. "They will prosper by selling access
to their music. They’ll become more entrepreneurial in how they
earn money, by selling merchandise and concert tickets. They’re
not making money on CDs now anyway."
While many of these
trends may scare the six-figure-salaried executives at the major
labels, it may actually be good news for smaller, niche-oriented
indie labels. Whitney Broussard, an entertainment lawyer at the New
York City law firm of Selverne, Mandelbaum & Mintz, says that
independents are gaining enormous power because of the Internet and
the democratization of music promotion. "One of the big issues
for 2005 will be this shift in power to the indie labels and
artists," he says. None of this is to say that major labels are
dead (they are still the best bet for those who want to become
mega-stars). But for the rest of us, do-it-yourself or indie routes
may prove a better way to make a living as an artist than in any
times past.
And that’s largely
because of the Internet and its nature as a cheap and efficient
distribution mechanism. "In 2005, indie record labels will gain
greater popularity and legitimacy among the musical
establishment," predicts culture-trends analyst Mario Almonte.
"It no longer requires millions of dollars to distribute a CD—just
several hundred dollars for a decent Web site."
At the same time,
companies are popping up everywhere to help artists better use the
Web. Many, such as iTunes, MusicMatch and the countless other song
download services, are well known. But even lesser known companies
are making a difference. Monkeycube,
for example, is a self-described counterculture Web site with 20,000
visitors per month looking to it for music reviews, among other
things.
In September 2004,
the company became an iTunes affiliate by embedding the purchasing
links into their reviews, making it easy for someone to impulsively
buy songs the minute they read about them. "To me, traditional
banner advertising is a dead medium, and I strongly believe that
affiliate programs will be the future of online music marketing in
2005," says Monkeycube founder Nathan Wright. "It’s very
tempting for Webmasters, because if they implement the program
successfully, they can start paying off those hosting bills or even
create new revenue streams. Plus, it’s tempting to artists because
readers can audition tracks in their homes while reading the review
and decide for themselves. Plus, they can buy the whole album within
a few clicks."
At the same time, the
Internet holds many opportunities and challenges for the traditional
music industry. Major labels, for example, are using the Web just as
vigorously if not more so than indie labels and artists. In fact,
Steven Rosenfeld, president of WorldWide Management and co-founder
of music publisher Smoking Caterpillar Music, warns that too much
reliance on the Internet in 2005 may limit reach for many artists
and labels. "The move just announced by Universal, for example,
to introduce several new bands online only cuts out, essentially, a
still large part of the music-buying public who prefer their music
on CD," he says. "Going online only may eliminate more
buyers than it will entice."
Whether that’s true
or not, the majors may give digital-only releases a shot in 2005:
Universal’s new digital-only label is UMe Digital, which in
November signed up eight relatively unknown bands in an effort to
test the theory that a label can promote bands without paying to
press and ship thousands of CDs to physical retail stores. Instead,
UMe Digital will use its promotional muscle to get the bands up on
iTunes and other download sites, as well as license their songs to
TV shows and movies. On the other hand, UMe Digital doesn’t
provide a big advance or many of the other perks associated with
traditional major-label deals.
And that’s not the
only way the majors are trying to evolve in 2005. Mitch Glazier, a
vice president at the Recording Industry Association of America,
recently predicted that several legitimate peer-to-peer services
(with the full sanction of major and indie labels) would start
popping up in 2005—allowing individuals to share songs online
without worrying about lawsuits. That could put an already popular
P2P phenomenon into hyperdrive, assuming the labels don’t screw it
up with unrealistic restrictions or draconian
digital-rights-management schemes.
In November, Sony
BMG, Universal Music Group and Warner Music Group inked a deal with
Wurld Media to create a new sanctioned P2P network called Peer
Impact. The service plans a full launch
in the first quarter of 2005. In addition, growing areas such as
"podcasting," which allows a Web site to easily stream
content, and other forms of Webcasting could give artists everywhere
even more exposure in 2005.
Beyond
Internet-specific trends, more general business changes are also
driving major shifts in the music industry. For one thing, the
consolidation wave that has already led to fewer major labels, radio
station owners, local music promoters and even booking agencies is
likely to continue into 2005 and beyond, which could further drive
talent to niche labels and services.
Indie bands going out
on the road face a dwindling number of clubs willing to book them.
In 2005, look for even more clubs to turn from live music to a
karaoke format—not the best news for indie artists trying to put
together a cohesive tour.
As some segments
shrink however, major label stars may even become bigger as their
labels focus more money and attention on fewer acts. Established
artists are also more able to monetize their fame by promoting other
products. Megastar Nelly, for example, began promoting his sugary
energy drink "Pimp Juice" in August 2003 and sold 6
million cans in the first year across 146 global markets.
As for sleeper trends
in 2005, how about the graying of America? The traditional music
industry has typically ignored older music buyers in favor of teens
and young adults. But in the current environment, the young are
often the least likely to buy music as they download, file share and
burn CDs to their hearts’ content.
Baby boomers, on the
other hand, have plenty of money to spend and aren’t as prone to
using P2P services. "There has been a momentous shift in the
demographic profile of music buyers," says Loyola University’s
Goolsby. "Even though there has been a tremendous increase in
the number of people under 25, music purchases have dropped in that
age group by almost 40 percent. Meanwhile, people over the age of 40
have doubled their percentage of music purchases. In fact, people
over 40 are the only people buying more, not less, music." Let’s
face it: The baby boomers can still rock, and they have more money
to spend in 2005 than ever.
To be sure, the march
of changes that have helped transform the music industry completely
in only a few short years will continue in 2005. With an explosion
of broadband Internet access and usage indie artists and labels are
benefiting from efficient and inexpensive access to online
distribution and promotion. The next year could lead to immense
opportunity—at least for those who know how to work a system that
has only recently turned itself upside down. And inside out. You get
the idea.
(Mike Grebb is a
writer, journalist and singer/songwriter based in Washington, D.C.
He has written for numerous publications, including Wired and
Billboard. He just completed his debut solo record, Resolution,
which is available at http://www.mikegrebb.com/).
|